The Old Dogs: How Bobby Bare’s Complaint to Shel Silverstein Became Country Music’s Funniest Last Stand

Somebody called Shel Silverstein “sir.”

That’s it. That’s the whole inciting incident. A stranger used a polite, harmless word, and it landed on a sixty-something bald, bearded songwriter, cartoonist, and children’s author like a diagnosis. Silverstein had spent his whole life being the youngest, wildest, most restless guy in whatever room he walked into — Playboy cartoonist, off-Broadway playwright, the man who wrote “A Boy Named Sue” for Johnny Cash and “The Unicorn” for the Irish Rovers, the author kids would grow up quoting from Where the Sidewalk Ends. Nobody had ever called him “sir” before. It made him, in his own words, feel depressingly old.

Around the same time, his old friend Bobby Bare — a Country Music Hall of Famer today, but in 1997 just a working singer well into his sixties, still touring, still recording, watching a Nashville that had gone all-in on twenty-five-year-olds in ball caps — had a complaint of his own. There weren’t any good songs about actually getting old. Not the greeting-card kind. Not the maudlin kind. The real kind — funny, honest, a little bit furious, the kind that told the truth about a body and a career both running out of road.

So Bare went to Silverstein with a proposition. “I went to Shel,” Bare said, “and I said, ‘we ain’t got no music, why don’t you write an album for us old farts?'”

Silverstein did. And what came out of that conversation became Old Dogs — a 1998 country supergroup built from four men who’d already lived entire careers by the time anyone thought to put them in a room together: Waylon Jennings, Mel Tillis, Bobby Bare, and Jerry Reed. It would turn out to be one of the strangest, funniest, and — though almost nobody clocked it at the time — most quietly moving records to come out of Nashville in the 1990s. It would also be the last thing Shel Silverstein ever finished.

Four Careers, One Complaint

To understand why four legends needed Shel Silverstein to write them an album about aging, you have to understand how much road each of them had already covered by 1998.

Bobby Bare was the one who started it. Born in Ironton, Ohio, in 1935, Bare had clawed his way into Nashville through Chet Atkins and RCA Victor, scoring a Grammy-winning hit with “Detroit City” in 1963 and following it with “500 Miles Away from Home” and “Four Strong Winds.” But Bare’s real gift wasn’t hitmaking in the conventional sense — it was ear. He was one of the first people in Nashville to recognize what a young Waylon Jennings could do, and one of the first to bet heavily on a strange, prolific songwriter named Shel Silverstein. Their 1973 concept album, Lullabys, Legends and Lies, produced Bare’s only number-one single, “Marie Laveau,” and a Grammy-nominated duet with his own five-year-old son called “Daddy What If.” Bare fought for creative control over his own recordings years before “outlaw country” was a marketing term anyone had coined — which made him, by his own account and by the account of the people around him, something closer to the movement’s actual first outlaw than its most famous ones.

Waylon Jennings needs less introduction — he was the closest thing outlaw country had to a flag. Born in Littlefield, Texas, in 1937, Jennings had survived the 1959 plane crash that killed Buddy Holly, Ritchie Valens, and the Big Bopper by giving up his seat, spent the late 1960s suffocating inside Nashville’s polished studio machine, and then in 1972 forced RCA into an unprecedented deal that gave him full creative control — a fight documented in CCTV’s account of that 1972 hospital standoff. By the time Old Dogs came together, Jennings had already lived an entire outlaw career: Honky Tonk Heroes, Wanted! The Outlaws, the Highwaymen, decades of amphetamine and cocaine use, and a hard-won sobriety in 1984. He was sixty years old in 1998, diabetic, and — though nobody quite said it out loud yet — running out of time.

Mel Tillis brought the comedy pedigree. Born in Florida in 1932, Tillis had overcome a lifelong stutter to become one of Nashville’s most prolific songwriters, penning more than a thousand songs including “Ruby, Don’t Take Your Love to Town,” a worldwide hit for Kenny Rogers. As a performer, Tillis had built his stutter into part of his stage persona — a source of genuine warmth and comedy rather than something he hid from — and had spent the 1970s racking up Top 10 hits and a CMA Entertainer of the Year award. By the late 1990s his hit-making days were behind him, but his gift for turning a self-deprecating joke into something an audience could love hadn’t gone anywhere.

Jerry Reed was, in the estimation of just about every guitarist who ever studied him, one of the best pickers Nashville ever produced — a “claw style” innovator whose playing influenced players from Chet Atkins on down, and whose songs “Guitar Man” and “U.S. Male” were covered by Elvis Presley with Reed himself playing lead. He’d had his own string of hits — “Amos Moses,” “When You’re Hot, You’re Hot,” “East Bound and Down” from Smokey and the Bandit — and a second career as a film actor, most recently playing the villain in Adam Sandler’s The Waterboy, released that same year, 1998. He was also, by every account, the group’s ringleader in terms of pure fun; the guy who’d turn a rehearsal into a comedy bit without trying.

Four careers, four decades, thousands of shows between them — and in 1997, all four men were watching Nashville radio move on without them. That wasn’t a complaint unique to Old Dogs. It’s the oldest story in country music, repeated every fifteen or twenty years as a new generation of twenty-five-year-olds takes over the airwaves and the men who built the format get politely nudged toward the county fair circuit. What made Old Dogs different is that instead of getting bitter about it quietly, or writing one more single that tried and failed to sound young, these four men decided to write an entire album about exactly what that felt like — and hand the pen to the one songwriter in Nashville who could make getting old sound like the funniest, most honest subject in the world.

“We Ain’t Got No Music for Old Farts”

The origin story of Old Dogs is small, specific, and completely believable — which is part of why it’s survived so cleanly in every retelling for almost thirty years. Bobby Bare and Shel Silverstein had been close friends and frequent collaborators since the early 1970s. Silverstein wasn’t just a hired songwriter to Bare; he was, in Bare’s own later description, “the greatest lyricist there ever was,” a man Bare trusted enough to hand an entire double album’s worth of material to sight unseen for Lullabys, Legends and Lies.

So when Bare — by then in his sixties, still touring, still recording, watching the country charts fill up with artists young enough to be his grandchildren — went looking for a project that actually reflected where he and his peers were in life, there was really only one person to call. He told Silverstein there wasn’t any good music out there about getting old. Not old age as a punchline you deliver from a distance, and not old age as a tragedy you’re supposed to weep quietly about — but old age as it actually is, lived day to day, with all its indignities and its dark jokes and its stubborn refusal to feel as finished as everyone assumes it should.

Silverstein, for his part, had his own reasons the subject had started gnawing at him. Being addressed as “sir” by a stranger — a small, ordinary courtesy — had rattled him in a way he found almost funny to admit. He’d spent his whole career being the youngest voice in the room: the guy writing raunchy folk songs in Greenwich Village nightclubs, the Playboy cartoonist sent around the world on assignment, the songwriter whose “Boy Named Sue” turned into a number-one hit for Johnny Cash almost by accident. Being quietly filed under “elderly” by someone who didn’t know any better apparently hit him harder than he expected.

“We ain’t got no music, why don’t you write an album for us old farts?”

Bobby Bare, on the request that started Old Dogs

Silverstein said yes — and then didn’t stop. What Bare had pitched as a handful of songs turned into an entire album’s worth of material, all built around the subject of aging: the humiliations, the vanities, the stubbornness, the dark comedy, and every so often, underneath all the punchlines, something genuinely sad. Silverstein wrote the whole thing himself. Every track on the finished record carries his songwriting credit.

From there, the roster built itself almost naturally. Bare needed voices who could sell material this specific and this personal — men who were actually living the subject matter, not performers doing a bit about old age from a safe distance. Waylon Jennings, Mel Tillis, and Jerry Reed were all longtime friends of Bare’s, all veterans of the same Nashville circuit, all in their sixties, and all — whether they said so out loud or not — hungry for a project that didn’t ask them to pretend to be twenty-eight years old for radio programmers who’d already moved on. In 1998, the four of them signed to Atlantic Records as Old Dogs, and went into the studio to record Silverstein’s songs.

Recorded Live, Warts and All

The most important production decision on Old Dogs almost never shows up in the track listing, but it shapes everything about how the record actually sounds: it was recorded live in the studio, in front of a small seated audience, with the applause and laughter left in between takes. This wasn’t a polished, overdubbed, radio-ready country record. It was closer to a filmed comedy special that happened to be an album — four old friends trading verses and one-liners in real time, in front of people who were genuinely laughing.

That choice matters because of what the songs were actually about. Silverstein hadn’t written safe, radio-friendly odes to graceful aging. He’d written material that was, in the words of period reviewers, “side-splitting and politically incorrect” — songs about no longer being able to “cut the mustard,” about being too tired to spread it around even if you could; about being told to “come back when you’re younger”; about couch potatoes, hearing aids, bad hips, and the particular indignity of a world that keeps assuming you’re finished. Eleven tracks on the first disc alone, all steel-guitar-driven, all built for an audience that was going to laugh out loud rather than nod along politely.

The final track listing ran to twenty-one songs across the two-volume release: “Old Dogs,” “Come Back When You’re Younger,” “I Don’t Do It No More,” “She’d Rather Be Homeless,” “Cut the Mustard,” “Young Man’s Job,” “When I Was,” “Couch Potato,” “Hard When It Ain’t,” “Jittabug,” and “Me and Jimmie Rodgers” made up the first half. The second half turned darker and stranger by design — “Elvis Has Left the Building,” “Wait Until Tomorrow,” “I Never Expected,” “Ever Lovin’ Machine,” “Slap My Face,” “Old Man’s Blues,” “Rough on the Livin’,” “Alimony,” “Still Gonna Die,” and finally “Time,” the album’s closing ballad — described by period listeners as bittersweet and unexpectedly wise, a deliberate tonal pivot away from the punchlines that dominated everything before it.

Jerry Reed took the lead vocal on “Young Man’s Job” and “Elvis Has Left the Building” — the latter a title possibly chosen in deference to Reed’s own history; Elvis Presley had recorded two of Reed’s own compositions, “Guitar Man” and “U.S. Male,” with Reed playing lead guitar on both sessions. Waylon Jennings, Mel Tillis, and Bobby Bare split the remaining lead vocals across the record, with the group trading verses on several tracks in the guitar-pull style that had defined Bare’s own television show, Bobby Bare and Friends, a decade earlier — passing a song from one voice to the next, the way old friends do when nobody’s in a hurry to end the night.

What the Songs Actually Said

It would be easy to file Old Dogs away as a novelty record — four old-timers making dirty jokes about hearing aids and hip replacements — and plenty of listeners at the time did exactly that. But underneath the punchlines, Silverstein was writing something sharper and more honest than the packaging let on.

The album’s title track set the tone immediately, built around a refrain that turned self-deprecation into defiance: old dogs, sure, but old dogs who can still bury a bone. That’s the whole album in one line. It isn’t a record about surrendering to age gracefully. It’s a record about middle fingers — funny ones, mostly, but middle fingers all the same. “Come Back When You’re Younger” and “Cut the Mustard” took direct aim at an industry that had already quietly filed all four of these men under “legacy act.” “Couch Potato” and “I Don’t Do It No More” mined the physical comedy of a body that no longer does what it used to. And “Rough on the Livin'” turned its attention to something darker and more specific: how a business that ignores its aging stars while they’re alive suddenly can’t stop celebrating them the moment they’re dead — a bitter little truth about Nashville’s relationship to its own legends that none of these four men needed Silverstein to explain to them personally.

Then there’s “Still Gonna Die,” a song that does exactly what its title promises — refuses to dress up mortality in anything softer than what it actually is — followed immediately by the album’s closer, “Time,” a genuinely tender ballad that period listeners singled out as unexpectedly wise, a deliberate change of key after twenty songs of jokes. Silverstein wasn’t just writing a comedy record. He was writing a record that used comedy as the delivery mechanism for something considerably more honest, and then, in its final minutes, dropped the joke entirely and told the truth straight.

That structure — funny, funny, funny, and then suddenly not — is the clearest evidence of what made Silverstein’s songwriting so effective across his whole career, whether he was writing children’s poetry or outlaw country hits for Bobby Bare, Waylon Jennings, or Johnny Cash. He never mocked the people in his songs. He empathized with them, all the way down, even the ones who were down on their luck or full of themselves or both. Old Dogs is no different. The jokes work because the men singing them were actually living the material — not performing old age from a safe, ironic distance, but describing something they were genuinely inside of.

The Last Thing Shel Ever Did

Old Dogs was released in 1998 on Atlantic Records, accompanied by a companion video release documenting the sessions. It didn’t chart the way Wanted! The Outlaws or Ol’ Waylon had decades earlier, and it was never going to; this was a record built for an audience Nashville radio had already stopped programming for, not one built to compete on the Hot Country charts of 1998. What it earned instead was something closer to a cult following among fans who’d grown up on all four of these men’s careers — and, with the passage of time, a reputation as one of the more quietly significant records of the decade, precisely because of what happened next.

Shel Silverstein died of a heart attack at his home in Key West, Florida, on May 10, 1999 — less than a year after Old Dogs was released, and roughly six months after the sessions themselves wrapped. He was 68 years old. Old Dogs turned out to be the last body of work he ever completed. By his own account, in the months before he died, he called it some of the most fun he’d ever had making anything — “harder work but more laughs,” in his words, “than anything I’ve ever done.”

Bobby Bare, who had spent more than two decades as Silverstein’s closest collaborator in Nashville, was blindsided by the loss in a way he wasn’t by the deaths of other friends his age. Silverstein, unlike so many of the hard-living Nashville figures in Bare’s circle, had always seemed like the one who took care of himself — the one nobody expected to go first. “We had a ton of fun,” Bare said afterward. “That’s the last thing Shel ever did.”

The timing gives Old Dogs a weight it clearly wasn’t written to carry. An album about the dark comedy of growing old, made by a songwriter who had no idea he was months from death, closing on a ballad literally titled “Time” — it’s the kind of coincidence that would feel manipulative in a scripted film and instead just sits there, plainly true, in the liner notes of a country record from 1998.

Four Lives After Old Dogs

Silverstein’s death was only the first. Over the following two decades, Old Dogs quietly became a document of an entire generation closing out — one voice at a time.

Waylon Jennings died on February 13, 2002, at his home in Chandler, Arizona, from complications related to diabetes. He was 64. His left foot had been amputated the year before, and he was too ill to attend his own induction into the Country Music Hall of Fame in October 2001, just months before he passed — a fuller account of his career and final years is covered in CCTV’s Waylon Jennings artist deep dive. For Jennings, Old Dogs sits among the very last studio work he ever completed — recorded four years before his death, at an age when he’d already outlived nearly every prediction anyone had made about him since that February night in 1959.

Jerry Reed died on September 1, 2008, in Nashville, of complications from emphysema. He was 71. He continued performing and recording almost to the end, and in 2017 — nine years after his death — he was finally inducted into the Country Music Hall of Fame, an honor Bobby Bare delivered in person on his behalf.

Mel Tillis died on November 19, 2017, in Ocala, Florida, of respiratory failure. He was 85, and had continued performing regularly at the Grand Ole Opry after rejoining as a cast member in 2007, following his own Hall of Fame induction that same year. His daughter, country star Pam Tillis, has continued honoring his songwriting legacy, including a full tribute album of his songs.

Bobby Bare is, remarkably, still with us. Born April 7, 1935, he turned 91 earlier this year and remains the last surviving member of Old Dogs. He was inducted into the Country Music Hall of Fame in 2013, rejoined the Grand Ole Opry as a member in 2018, and has continued recording and performing well into his nineties — including a 2017 album, Things Change, featuring a guest turn from Chris Stapleton. Of all the friends he watched pass — Chet Atkins, Cliffie Stone, Harlan Howard, Waylon Jennings — Bare has said Silverstein’s death was the one he saw coming least. Everyone else, in his telling, gave some kind of warning. Shel didn’t.

What that leaves behind is a strange, specific kind of document: a comedy album about growing old, made by four men in their sixties who between them had roughly two more decades of life left, recorded with a songwriter who had less than a year — and a single survivor now well into his nineties who can still, by all accounts, tell you exactly what the joke was.

Why It Still Matters

Old Dogs never set out to be a landmark record, and calling it one now would probably make all four men laugh. It wasn’t built to compete on the charts, and it wasn’t built to be taken seriously — that was more or less the entire point. But almost thirty years on, it’s worth something that has nothing to do with chart position.

It’s one of the only records in country music history built entirely around the specific experience of aging out of an industry that runs almost exclusively on youth — made not by outsiders commenting on that experience, but by four men who were living it in real time, alongside the one songwriter who could make that experience sound like the funniest, most honest subject in Nashville. It’s the last complete work by a man who helped write “A Boy Named Sue,” “Sylvia’s Mother,” and some of Bobby Bare’s greatest recordings — a songwriter whose full catalog is covered in CCTV’s deep dive on Shel Silverstein’s hidden role in outlaw country. And it’s one of the last studio recordings by Waylon Jennings, made near the very end of a life that had already reshaped what a country artist was allowed to demand from Nashville.

Mostly, though, Old Dogs matters because of what it refused to do. It refused to let four legendary careers end on a quiet fade-out, and it refused to let getting old be a subject nobody in country music was honest about. Bobby Bare complained that there wasn’t any good music about it. Shel Silverstein wrote an album’s worth in response. And somewhere in the middle of all those jokes about hearing aids and hip replacements, four old friends recorded something that turned out to be considerably more honest — and more lasting — than anyone in that room expected it to be.

At Classic Country TV, our goal is simple — keep the stories behind the songs alive. Old Dogs is a small, strange, funny corner of country music history that deserves exactly that kind of remembering.

Listen, Read & Collect: Old Dogs and Outlaw Country Picks

As an Amazon Associate, Classic Country TV earns from qualifying purchases.

Disclosure: Some links on this page are affiliate links. If you purchase through these links, Classic Country TV may earn a small commission at no additional cost to you.

Guitar & Instruments

Yamaha FG800 Solid Top Folk Acoustic Guitar
Jerry Reed spent forty years proving what a plain, honest acoustic guitar can do in the right hands. The FG800 is the same idea in beginner form — a solid spruce top that opens up as you play it, built for someone who wants to actually learn the songs, not just look the part.
https://www.amazon.com/dp/B01CTFRTCK?tag=classiccoun08-20

D’Addario NS Tri-Action Guitar Capo
A simple, single-hand capo built for buzz-free playing at any fret — the kind of no-nonsense gear that would’ve fit right in a guitar case backstage at an Old Dogs session.
https://www.amazon.com/dp/B008BPI3AA?tag=classiccoun08-20

Bar & Whiskey Accessories

Godinger Whiskey Decanter and 4 Cocktail Glasses Bar Set
Classic, no-gimmicks barware for anyone toasting four old friends who refused to go quietly. Godinger’s been making handcrafted glassware since 1973 — old-school in the best way.
https://www.amazon.com/dp/B07GVQ7TQ7?tag=classiccoun08-20

Stainless Steel Whiskey Stones Gift Set in Wooden Barrel Box
Reusable chilling stones that keep a pour cold without watering it down — a fitting nod to an album that never once apologized for taking its time.
https://www.amazon.com/dp/B0B3NK36NF?tag=classiccoun08-20

Grooming & Western Style

Viking Revolution Ultimate Beard Kit
Brush, comb, balm, oil, and scissors in one travel tin — for anyone who’d rather age like Bobby Bare than fight it. Old Dogs might have laughed at the whole idea of “aging gracefully,” but there’s nothing wrong with looking sharp while you do it your own way.
https://www.amazon.com/dp/B07B53Q3BX?tag=classiccoun08-20

Old Spice Classic Pomade
A straightforward, medium-hold pomade with a barbershop-era pedigree — the kind of unfussy grooming staple that four Nashville legends in their sixties wouldn’t have thought twice about.
https://www.amazon.com/dp/B08NRSVR3S?tag=classiccoun08-20

From the CCTV Shop

Classic Country. No Apologies. — Outlaw Shield Tee ($32.99)
For fans who know Old Dogs wasn’t a footnote — it was four outlaws refusing to fade quietly. A clean, bold design for listeners who take the real history seriously.
https://classiccountrytv.com/products/classic-country-no-apologies-outlaw-shield-tee

Who’s Gonna Fill Their Shoes? — The Legends Tribute Hardcover Journal ($24.85)
A tribute-series journal built for fans keeping their own record of the legends who shaped this music — fitting company for a story about four of them refusing to be counted out.
https://classiccountrytv.com/products/whos-gonna-fill-their-shoes-the-legends-tribute-hardcover-journal

Sources

Wikipedia — Old Dogs (group)
Overview of the group’s formation, membership, and recording details.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Old_Dogs_(group)

Cherry Red Records — Old Dogs: Volumes One & Two
Liner-note history of the album’s origin, including direct quotes from Bobby Bare and Shel Silverstein on the project’s beginnings.
https://www.cherryred.co.uk/old-dogs-volumes-one-two-cd

The Official Bobby Bare Website — Biography
Bare’s own account of his friendship with Shel Silverstein and his reaction to Silverstein’s death.
https://www.bobbybare.com/biography

Wikipedia — Bobby Bare
Career chronology, chart history, and confirmation of Bare’s status as the last surviving member of Old Dogs.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bobby_Bare

Wikipedia — Jerry Reed
Biographical details, death date, and career overview including his role in Old Dogs.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jerry_Reed

Britannica — Mel Tillis
Biographical overview including his role in Old Dogs and career details.
https://www.britannica.com/biography/Mel-Tillis

Wikipedia — Waylon Jennings
Career chronology, health decline, and death details.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Waylon_Jennings

The Recoup — Old Dogs: Old Dogs, Volumes One & Two (Morello Records) Review
Retrospective critical analysis of the album’s tone, themes, and legacy.
https://therecoup.com/2017/05/22/old-dogs-old-dogs-volumes-1-2-morello-records/

Country Music Hall of Fame and Museum — Jerry Reed
Career biography and details on Reed’s later years and posthumous Hall of Fame induction.
https://www.countrymusichalloffame.org/hall-of-fame/jerry-reed

---

Frequently Asked Questions