The Day Merle Haggard Told Sturgill Simpson He Was the Only One Worth Listening To

In the spring of 2016, down a dirt road outside Redding, California, a magazine writer and a photographer pulled up to a ranch house with a plain white fence. Inside, on an ordinary sectional sofa, sat two men who represented, between them, nearly the entire arc of outlaw country music. One was 78 years old, a former convict turned Bakersfield legend who had written some of the most honest songs in the genre’s history. The other was 37, a former Navy sailor and railroad worker from Kentucky who had just spent two years being called the second coming of everything country music was supposed to be but rarely was anymore.

Merle Haggard and Sturgill Simpson were not strangers. They had shared a stage before. But this was different — an invitation, a day off from touring carved out on purpose, wives sent to the store for fish tacos so the two men could sit and talk. Garden & Gun magazine was there to capture it for their April/May 2016 music issue, in a feature called “The Legend and the Renegade,” written by Matt Hendrickson with photographs by David McClister. Less than a year later, that conversation would read very differently than it did the day it was published — not because anything in it changed, but because of what happened next.

This is the story of that afternoon — what was actually said, what it meant at the time, and why, in hindsight, it plays like one of the last times country music’s old guard formally handed something to the new.

---

Also on Classic Country TV: Merle Haggard didn’t just represent the Bakersfield Sound — he lived everything that sound was built on. Here’s the full story of a legendary career. Read Merle Haggard’s Artist Deep Dive

---

Two Roads to the Same Ranch

To understand why this particular meeting mattered, you have to understand how differently these two men arrived at that sofa.

Merle Haggard’s path to Redding ran through Oildale, the Dust Bowl-settled community just north of Bakersfield where he was born in 1937 and, by his own account, raised partly in a converted boxcar his parents had hauled west from Oklahoma. His father died when Haggard was nine, and what followed was a boyhood that drifted, then unraveled — truancy, petty theft, stretches in juvenile facilities, and eventually a burglary charge that landed him in San Quentin State Prison in the late 1950s. It was there, in the prison yard on New Year’s Day, 1958, that Haggard watched Johnny Cash perform for the inmates. Cash had been up all night in San Francisco and could barely talk above a whisper by the time he took the stage, but he held five thousand prisoners in the palm of his hand anyway. Haggard would later say that performance — and the simple fact that music could command that kind of room — was part of what convinced him there was a different life available to him than the one he’d been living.

He was paroled in 1960 and started working the Bakersfield club circuit almost immediately, singing in bars for tips while the town itself was becoming something bigger than a farm-labor outpost in the San Joaquin Valley. Bakersfield in the early 1960s was producing a sound of its own — twangy, Telecaster-driven, built for dancing and drinking rather than string sections and choir backing vocals — largely as a reaction against the smoothed-over “Nashville Sound” that was dominating country radio at the time. Buck Owens led that charge first, turning venues like the Blackboard Cafe into a proving ground for a harder, more electric brand of country than Nashville wanted much to do with. Haggard, a few years behind him, became its second great voice, and eventually its conscience — the one who kept writing about prison, poverty, and hard living long after Owens had crossed over into television and lighter fare.

What Haggard built from there is one of the most decorated careers in country music history: 38 number-one singles, a songwriting catalog that included “Mama Tried,” “Sing Me Back Home,” “Hungry Eyes,” and “Workin’ Man Blues,” and a permanent place, alongside Willie Nelson, Waylon Jennings, and Johnny Cash, on what people in Nashville sometimes call the Mount Rushmore of outlaw country.

That label wasn’t just a nickname handed out after the fact. By the mid-1970s, Haggard, Nelson, Jennings, and a handful of others had become closely associated with a real shift in how country music got made — artists pushing back against Nashville’s tightly controlled studio system, insisting on writing and producing their own material, and leaning into rougher, more personal songs than the label-approved formula allowed. In 1976, RCA packaged some of that material into a compilation called Wanted! The Outlaws, and it became the first country album certified platinum, giving the whole movement a name that stuck. Haggard was never on that particular record — he was signed elsewhere — but he was unmistakably part of the same current, the same insistence that a country song ought to sound like it came from a real life rather than a formula. It’s the tradition Simpson would later be measured against, whether he asked for the comparison or not.

By 2016, Haggard was living quietly on more than 250 acres outside Redding — not in a mansion, but in that same modest ranch house, cozy and lived-in, the kind of place a working man builds when the work finally pays off. He’d shipped in an old train bridge to cross the property’s pond, a small, deliberate nod to his railroading days. Behind the house sat a building that functioned as his recording studio, with an attached outdoor stage and a parking spot reserved for a tour bus he had, against his family’s wishes, just bought.

Sturgill Simpson’s road to that ranch started more than two thousand miles away, in Jackson, Kentucky, a small town in Breathitt County where he was born on June 8, 1978, the only child of a secretary and a state police narcotics investigator. His mother’s family had worked the coal mines for generations. Simpson was the first man on that side of the family who didn’t have to go underground for a living — a fact he’d later credit to his grandfather, who filled the cab of the Bronco he drove to a strip-mine job with Merle Haggard and Marty Robbins cassettes and, in doing so, handed Simpson the music that would eventually give him a way out of following the rest of the family into the mines.

He enlisted in the Navy straight out of high school, in 1996, and spent three years in the Combat Information Center aboard the USS Rodney M. Davis, a frigate that carried him through stretches at sea and time stationed in Japan. He’s since said the Navy never really fit him. When his enlistment ended in 1999, he drifted to the Pacific Northwest, waiting tables at an IHOP outside Seattle while he tried to figure out what came next, before eventually moving back home to Lexington. A band called Sunday Valley followed in 2004, and with it a first, unsuccessful attempt at Nashville the following year. It didn’t take. In 2006, Simpson gave up on music altogether and moved to Salt Lake City, Utah, to work for Union Pacific Railroad — a detail that would turn out to matter more to this particular conversation than either man could have planned. He spent four years there, working his way from freight operations up to an operations-management role, making good, steady money doing work that had nothing to do with songwriting.

It was his wife, Sarah, who pulled him back. She and Simpson had met before Utah, and when she saw where four years of railroad work and a self-described spiral of nihilism had left him, she bought him a four-track recorder and told him, in essence, that he owed it to himself to try music again. In 2010, the two of them quit their jobs and moved to Nashville together. Simpson revived Sunday Valley, then went solo, and in 2013 — at 35 years old, later than most artists get their real start — he self-funded and released his debut album, High Top Mountain, a dozen hard-country, honky-tonk tracks written as a tribute to the Kentucky he’d grown up in. It made barely a ripple outside a small circle of critics and fellow songwriters. Simpson has said since that he considers it, in some ways, the more carefully crafted of his early records — he put more deliberate work into those songs than what came next.

What came next changed everything. In 2014, Simpson booked a week of studio time with producer Dave Cobb, and in four days they cut Metamodern Sounds in Country Music — a record made fast, loose, and almost entirely without a plan. It didn’t sound like anything else on country radio that year. Critics reached for outlaw-country language to describe Simpson because there wasn’t really another vocabulary available: here was a singer with a voice that echoed Waylon Jennings, writing songs that refused the genre’s dominant sound of the mid-2010s — the pickup trucks, the beach parties, the drum-machine choruses — in favor of something stranger, sparser, and considerably more honest. The album earned Simpson a Grammy nomination for Best Americana Album, a spot on Rolling Stone’s list of the year’s best albums, and a place among NPR’s favorites for 2014.

He wasn’t chasing outlaw country as an image. He was living the same math the outlaws had always lived — a family at home, a bus on the road, and no good way to have both at once.

By early 2016, Simpson was finishing A Sailor’s Guide to Earth, a concept album written as an open letter to his infant son, due out that April on Atlantic Records — his first release for a major label. It drew on his own three years in the Navy for its imagery, framing a father’s advice to a child he’d inevitably have to leave behind for long stretches, as a sailor’s own life had once required of him. He had just become a father, and he was about to spend the next year mostly away from his family to support the record — a tension that, as it turned out, was going to sit at the center of his conversation with Haggard.

How a Kentucky Railroad Man Found His Way to Merle Haggard’s Sofa

The two men had crossed paths before — first at a festival where they wound up on the same stage together, and later at a joint show with Chris Stapleton in Minnesota, at the Bluestem Center for the Arts in Moorhead. That Minnesota booking wasn’t an accident. Around the same time, Haggard was telling other interviewers that most of what passed for contemporary country left him cold — he found little melody in it and even less substance — and that Simpson, specifically, was the one act among the new generation he considered worth his attention. Speaking to one interviewer that spring, Haggard put it about as plainly as a compliment can be put: as far as he was concerned, Simpson was the only thing coming out of Nashville in years that he’d actually wanted to listen to.

That kind of praise, coming from Haggard, carried weight precisely because he handed it out so rarely. This was not a man given to easy flattery, and it was certainly not a man in the habit of inviting opening acts he didn’t respect onto his own bill — which is exactly what he’d done, personally asking Simpson to open that Minnesota show.

Simpson, for his part, had grown up on Haggard’s music by inheritance rather than discovery, thanks to his grandfather’s cassette collection. Of everything that played in that Bronco, “Big City” is the song Simpson remembers as his true introduction to Haggard — soundtracking a working man’s daily commute long before Simpson understood what a career in music might look like for himself.

What pulled Haggard’s attention toward Simpson, meanwhile, was a single song: “Long White Line,” off Metamodern Sounds — a road song, plainspoken and a little weary, about the distance between a touring musician and the person waiting for him at home. Haggard has described being struck less by any specific lyric than by a sense that Simpson understood exactly what he was reaching for and had the skill to hit it. Coming from a songwriter who had spent decades writing his own versions of that same distance, it wasn’t a casual compliment.

When the two men sat down together that day at the ranch, Simpson admitted something that might have surprised fans who only knew him from the outside looking in — that he wasn’t entirely sure Metamodern Sounds was even the better record of his two. He’d worked harder, dug deeper, and taken more time crafting High Top Mountain, his self-funded 2013 tribute to the honky-tonk music of his home state. Metamodern had come together in four days flat, cut almost on a whim during a shared gap in his and producer Dave Cobb’s schedules, with no real plan beyond seeing what happened when they got in a room together. Simpson seemed to view its runaway success with a mixture of gratitude and mild disbelief, the way a man looks at a hand he wasn’t necessarily trying to draw — a Grammy nomination for Best Americana Album, a spot on year-end best-of lists from Rolling Stone and NPR, and a cultural foothold that the more painstaking High Top Mountain had never quite found.

The Ranch, the Bus, and a Rare Day Off

The day itself was built around absence as much as presence. Both men’s wives headed into town to shop for that night’s dinner — fish tacos — which left Haggard and Simpson alone on the sofa for the conversation Hendrickson would eventually shape into “The Legend and the Renegade.” It’s worth sitting with how unusual that setup was. This wasn’t a green-room interview squeezed between soundchecks, or a phone call routed through three layers of publicists. It was two working musicians, on a day neither of them was contractually obligated to be anywhere, talking the way two people talk when nobody’s rushing them.

The physical setting mattered too. A ranch that doubled as a working studio and rehearsal space, a pond crossed by a train bridge Haggard had specifically shipped in to honor his railroading past, a tour bus sitting in the driveway that Haggard’s own family had been begging him to park for good. Every detail of the property told the same story the conversation was about to tell out loud: a man who had built a life designed to let him keep touring, even as touring cost him more than it once had.

There’s something worth noting in the fact that a magazine crew was there to see any of it. Haggard wasn’t a mystery to the press by 2016 — he’d given thousands of interviews across five decades — but he wasn’t in the habit of opening the ranch itself to a writer and a photographer for an unhurried, unstructured afternoon. That he did it for Simpson, and did it on a day he could have simply spent resting between tour dates, says something about how much weight he put on the visit before a single question had even been asked.

What Merle Haggard and Sturgill Simpson Actually Talked About

Interviews built around two artists in conversation can drift into pleasantries. This one didn’t. From nearly the first question, Haggard and Simpson were talking about the actual cost of the life they’d both chosen — and neither one dressed it up.

That candor is worth pausing on. Haggard had given interviews for the better part of five decades by 2016, and like most artists who’ve done thousands of them, he had a well-worn set of stories he could tell on autopilot — the boxcar childhood, the San Quentin years, the Bakersfield bars. None of that shorthand shows up here. Whether it was the absence of a third party in the room, the fact that both wives had genuinely stepped out rather than lingering nearby, or simply Haggard’s evident comfort with Simpson specifically, the conversation reads less like a promotional obligation and more like two men who happened to have a tape recorder running while they talked about things they might not otherwise have said out loud.

Haggard’s family, he admitted plainly, wanted him to quit the road. He couldn’t. He described touring as a genuine contradiction — the thing that kept him alive and the thing that damaged his life in equal measure, a tension he said he tried to manage by building something stable at the ranch and then leaving it behind, again and again, to climb back on the bus. Simpson recognized the shape of that problem immediately, because he was living an early version of it himself. His son had been born right around the time Metamodern Sounds broke through, and Simpson spent much of that first year of his son’s life on tour, watching him grow up mostly through photographs sent from the road. He called it the hardest part of the transition his family had been through — bittersweet, some days barely tolerable, even while he understood how much better off his family was because the record had taken off.

Haggard, older and further down that same road, offered something closer to a shrug than a solution — an old line about how the surest way to make God laugh is to tell him your plans. Simpson met it with his own version of the same idea: you don’t look a gift horse in the mouth, not when the gift horse is what’s paying to raise your family — even if the price is time you’ll never get back, and even if the alternative, as Simpson put it, was going back to stocking shelves in a grocery store while trying to scrape together a career as a songwriter on the side.

Neither man pretended the trade-off was a fair one. That’s what makes the exchange worth remembering — not as advice, exactly, since neither offered any, but as two men from different generations arriving at the same honest, unresolved answer: you don’t get to keep everything. You choose what you’re willing to lose, and you live with having chosen it.

The Railroad Connection Nobody Expected

One of the more unexpected threads in the conversation was about trains — not as metaphor, but as shared lived experience. Both men had worked railroads before music worked out, and both described something like a fraternity among people who’d done that specific, dangerous, physically demanding job. Haggard compared it to the recognition that passes between two people who’ve each done time in prison — an instant, wordless understanding of what the other person has carried.

Simpson picked up the thread and turned it personal: the sound of a passing train, or a distant horn, hits him differently now than it did before he made music his living — it’s become something closer to a reminder of exactly why he keeps working at this, rather than going back to what came before. Haggard answered in kind — he’d been around enough railroaders to know how physically and mentally punishing that work could be, the kind of job where you could lose your life in a single careless second, and hearing a train whistle now only reminded him he had no interest in going back to it either.

It’s a small moment in the piece, easy to skim past. But it says something real about why these two men connected in the first place. It wasn’t primarily about musical influence. It was about two people who’d both done hard, dangerous, working-class labor before music gave them a way out — and who each recognized, in the other, someone who hadn’t forgotten what that cost.

That shared history put Haggard and Simpson in a smaller club than their catalogs alone might suggest. Plenty of country artists have sung about working-class life without having lived much of it themselves. Haggard had done actual time on actual railroads and in an actual prison cell before he ever made a living with a guitar. Simpson had spent four years climbing the ranks at a Utah freight yard, doing a job methodical and physically demanding enough that Nashville’s version of hard work — long nights, long drives — probably felt, by comparison, like a different kind of hard. Neither man needed to research what he was writing about. That’s a distinction the two of them clearly recognized in each other without needing to say it outright.

How Merle Haggard Actually Wrote Songs — And Why It Mattered to Sturgill Simpson

Ask most songwriters about their process and you’ll get a routine — a time of day, a ritual, a discipline. Haggard offered something closer to the opposite of a system. He described having no real method at all: no scheduled sitting-down-to-write, no forcing it. When a song arrived, it arrived, and the only real skill involved was being ready to catch it — on paper, on a recorder, however you could manage — before it slipped away again. He’d been writing since childhood, filling notebooks with songs he later admitted weren’t any good, learning slowly which ideas were worth chasing and which weren’t. The good ones, he said, felt less like something he built and more like something handed to him.

Someone once asked Roger Miller if he had any songwriting advice to offer a younger performer, and Miller’s answer — the kind of dry, sideways wisdom Haggard clearly loved repeating — was simply not to carry your guitar picks and your pills in the same box. Haggard passed that one along to Simpson at the ranch, along with a piece of advice he credited to Willie Nelson: do the work you actually want to do, because the moment people start liking it, you’re going to have to keep doing it. Haggard framed it as advice for Simpson specifically — that whatever he was doing, however far outside the mainstream it sat, he should keep doing exactly that, because it was working, and because Haggard, for his part, was simply a fan waiting to hear what came next.

Both pieces of advice, taken together, amount to something more coherent than a couple of jokes strung end to end. Miller’s line was about discipline — about not letting the parts of your life that help you cope bleed into the part of your life that’s supposed to be your work. Nelson’s was about ownership — about trusting your own instincts enough that you’re willing to live with the consequences of an audience actually liking what you made. Haggard had spent a career learning both lessons the hard way, and handing them off to Simpson, unprompted, in the middle of an afternoon that wasn’t framed as a mentorship at all, is as close as the conversation ever comes to Haggard consciously trying to pass something down.

What Haggard admired in Simpson, beyond the songs themselves, was the absence of compromise around them. Simpson wasn’t answering to anyone else’s idea of what a bandleader should sound like, wasn’t chasing trends, wasn’t diluting his sound to fit someone else’s format. Haggard, by contrast, remembered stretches of his own career when he’d carried an oversized band, at one point running two drummers at once — a decision he’d since come to see less as a flex than a mistake worth not repeating.

Simpson, in turn, credited Haggard’s live shows with teaching him something about pacing he still used — how to move continuously from song to song without breaking momentum for stage patter, partly because Simpson has always found the expectation to entertain between songs genuinely nerve-wracking. It’s a detail that humanizes an artist who, by 2016, had already been anointed by critics as country music’s most fearless new voice: even Sturgill Simpson gets nervous talking to a crowd.

There’s an easy, almost throwaway moment in the conversation that captures the tone of the whole afternoon better than any of the heavier material. Talking about the oversized band he used to carry, Haggard mentioned he’d once had two drummers going at the same time. Simpson’s response wasn’t reverence — it was a genuinely puzzled question about how anyone finds two good drummers in the first place, let alone hires them both. Haggard’s answer, in effect, was that he’d learned his lesson. It’s a small exchange, but it’s the kind of thing that only happens between people who’ve stopped performing respect for each other and settled into something closer to friendship — two musicians talking shop, not a legend granting an audience.

---

Also on Classic Country TV: Long before Sturgill Simpson, a generation of outlaw songwriters built the tradition he inherited — the story of the writers who made the movement’s bones. Read the story of Billy Joe Shaver and outlaw country’s songwriters

---

“I Don’t Find No Substance”: Haggard’s Honest Take on Modern Country

Haggard didn’t soften his opinion of where mainstream country had drifted by 2016, and Simpson didn’t ask him to. When the conversation turned toward Simpson’s own forthcoming record, A Sailor’s Guide to Earth, Simpson admitted he wasn’t even certain it qualified as a country album by the industry’s current definition. Haggard’s response was blunt approval: if it didn’t sound like what the mainstream was calling country these days, that was a point in its favor, not against it. He’d said as much to other interviewers that same spring, describing the genre’s commercial center as having lost the melodic and lyrical substance he’d spent his career trying to protect — the kind of songs, he complained, that nobody could even whistle anymore.

This wasn’t nostalgia for its own sake. Haggard had made a similar, more specific argument years earlier, in a 2009 interview where he’d said flatly that country music would never return to its roots. Asked about it again at the ranch, he revised the framing slightly rather than the substance: he didn’t think the industry would ever pass that way again, because the environment that had produced it no longer existed. He traced the shift to something concrete and historical — the mass closure of U.S. Army bases across the country, each of which had once supported several bars, and the resulting collapse of the live bar circuit that had functioned, whether anyone called it that at the time or not, as country music’s unofficial trade school. When that circuit disappeared, Haggard argued, an entire generation of would-be pickers lost the only place they could have learned the craft in front of a real, paying, unforgiving audience — the kind of room where a musician either sharpened up fast or got replaced by someone who would.

Simpson recognized the pattern immediately from the other end of the timeline. He described watching the same collapse continue in real time — fewer venues booking live bands at all, DJs and dance nights replacing full sets, young musicians left with only a handful of towns, mostly Nashville and Austin, where they could still play the long, unglamorous cover-band sets that used to be how every working musician learned their instrument under pressure. It’s a genuinely useful piece of oral history — two working musicians from different generations independently arriving at the same diagnosis of what country music actually lost when the honky-tonk circuit died, and why no amount of nostalgia can simply will it back into existence.

It’s worth pointing out, too, that Simpson wasn’t simply agreeing to flatter an idol. He’d lived a version of Haggard’s argument from the other direction — playing four- and five-hour cover sets in whatever bar would have him during his own lean years in Nashville, the kind of grinding, unglamorous stage time that either teaches a musician to read a room or gets him fired from the gig. When those rooms disappear, as both men agreed they largely had, the education disappears with them. There’s no shortcut that replaces years of playing to a half-empty bar on a Tuesday night and learning, the hard way, which songs actually work.

Merle Haggard on Dolly Parton, and a Song That Was Never Recorded

The conversation wasn’t all analysis. There’s real warmth in the piece, particularly when Simpson brought up seeing Dolly Parton play the Glastonbury Festival to a crowd he estimated at 120,000 people, close enough to feel her energy from a mile away, and suggested Haggard ought to try Europe himself sometime — a continent that has always loved American country music with a devotion Nashville doesn’t always return.

Haggard lit up at the memory of touring America with Parton across 1974 and 1975, calling her one of the most charismatic performers he’d ever shared a stage with and recalling that period as one where she was writing at a ferocious pace — turning out songs during that very stretch that would go on to become some of the most enduring in her catalog, including “Jolene,” “I Will Always Love You,” and “Coat of Many Colors.” It’s a brief, almost incidental exchange in the larger conversation, but it’s a useful reminder that Haggard’s outlaw reputation never came at the expense of genuine warmth toward his peers. He wasn’t guarded about who he admired, and he clearly loved talking about the people who’d impressed him over a five-decade career, Simpson included.

But the moment in the interview that carries the most weight in hindsight comes near the very end, almost as an aside. Simpson referenced a song Haggard had played for him privately, on the bus — one Simpson clearly considered exceptional, telling Haggard that if he had nine more songs of that caliber sitting around, he was in about as good a creative position as a songwriter could be. Haggard’s answer was quiet and final: he’d never recorded it. It simply didn’t exist anywhere except that one afternoon on the bus.

A song good enough to stop Sturgill Simpson mid-sentence — and it never made it further than a tour bus and Merle Haggard’s memory.

Haggard went on, in the interview’s closing passage, to describe a specific kind of creative restlessness — an anxiousness that builds when he goes too long without writing something he considers worthwhile, a need to say something that matters given how much was happening in the world at the time. Simpson responded with an observation from his own wife, using a railroad image that closed the loop on everything the two men had already talked about that day: it’s hard to judge how fast a train is actually moving when you’re the one riding it. Haggard’s reply, and the piece’s final line, was a quiet kind of promise between two songwriters — that there might be a song worth writing in that idea yet.

---

Also on Classic Country TV: Willie Nelson spent his own career blurring the line between outlaw and elder statesman — the same balance Haggard was still working out on that ranch. Read Willie Nelson’s Artist Deep Dive

---

What Happened After the Interview Ran

“The Legend and the Renegade” was published in Garden & Gun’s April/May 2016 issue — meaning it hit newsstands right around, and possibly even after, one of the most significant dates in the story: Merle Haggard died on April 6, 2016, his 79th birthday, at his home in nearby Palo Cedro, California, following a long battle with pneumonia. The interview’s own text carries an unintentional weight in that light. At one point, discussing future tour plans with Simpson, Haggard had joked that the two of them were going to play a lot more shows together — “if I don’t die or something.” It’s the kind of throwaway line that reads completely differently once you know what came next.

The relationship between the two men didn’t end with Haggard’s death — if anything, Simpson became one of the loudest public defenders of what Haggard had actually stood for, as opposed to how the industry chose to memorialize him. That August, the Academy of Country Music announced it would present a newly created “Merle Haggard Spirit Award” to Miranda Lambert. Simpson responded with a lengthy, furious public statement accusing the ACM of invoking Haggard’s name for an awards-show spectacle while ignoring, as Simpson put it, exactly what Haggard had actually thought of the mainstream country establishment during his lifetime.

Simpson didn’t stop at the ACM. In that same statement, he turned his frustration toward Garden & Gun itself — the very magazine that had run “The Legend and the Renegade” only months earlier. According to Simpson’s account, the magazine had originally planned to put both Haggard and himself on the cover of that April/May issue, and Haggard had made himself available for a two-hour outdoor photo shoot with McClister to make it happen, despite still recovering from the pneumonia that would ultimately contribute to his death. At the last minute, Simpson said, the magazine’s editors pulled the cover and replaced it with Chris Stapleton instead, without warning either artist’s camp until the issue had already gone to print. Simpson didn’t blame Stapleton for any of it — the two shared a publicist, and Simpson later credited Stapleton with personally calling to express his own frustration over how it had been handled — but Simpson’s anger at the magazine itself was plain: two hours of a dying man’s time, he suggested, deserved better than an editor’s last-minute change of heart.

Simpson later clarified that his criticism of the ACM’s award wasn’t aimed at Lambert personally — he noted Haggard had liked and respected her — but he stood by the larger point. He also predicted, in the same post, that he’d likely be frozen out by Nashville’s industry establishment for saying any of it publicly, and said that outcome didn’t particularly bother him. The prediction drew immediate attention: fellow songwriter Jason Isbell voiced his agreement on social media before he’d even finished reading Simpson’s full statement, then reaffirmed it once he had. Coverage of the episode spread from country-music outlets to national entertainment desks within a day.

By the fall of that year, in a separate interview reflecting on the controversy, Simpson had softened his stance on Nashville itself, if not on the substance of what he’d said. He described his prediction of being blackballed as something closer to a reflexive reaction in an emotional moment, and made clear he had no intention of leaving the city or the industry behind. In that same interview, he made a decision that reads, in hindsight, like the practical follow-through on everything he and Haggard had talked about that afternoon at the ranch: rather than walk away from Nashville the way earlier generations of outlaws sometimes had, he said he intended to make the city something closer to a personal project — to stay, on his own terms, and let the work speak for itself.

It’s worth pausing on how directly that public stand — the fury, and the eventual second thought that followed it — traces back to the ranch conversation five months earlier. Haggard hadn’t handed Simpson a mission statement that day. But he had modeled, out loud, exactly the kind of blunt, unsentimental honesty about the country music industry that Simpson would go on to invoke, almost word for word in spirit, when he thought Haggard’s legacy was being misused. And the album Simpson had been nervously previewing for Haggard that very afternoon — the one he wasn’t even sure counted as a country record — went on to prove Haggard’s blunt approval right. A Sailor’s Guide to Earth would go on to win the Grammy for Best Country Album at the 59th Grammy Awards, alongside a nomination for Album of the Year, the kind of validation that neither man could have known, sitting on that sofa in early 2016, was only months away.

The Song That Might Have Finally Gotten Written

There’s one more thread worth following, though it has to be handled with the right amount of caution. In December 2020, Simpson released Cuttin’ Grass, Vol. 2: The Cowboy Arms Sessions, a bluegrass reinterpretation of his own catalog. Among the previously unreleased tracks was a song called “Hobo Cartoon,” credited as co-written with the late Merle Haggard. According to reporting at the time, Haggard had sent Simpson the track before his death, and Simpson finished it himself years later, calling it a fitting homage given how much Haggard loved bluegrass music.

Whether “Hobo Cartoon” is the same unrecorded song Simpson heard on Haggard’s bus that afternoon in 2016 has never been publicly confirmed by either party, and Classic Country TV isn’t going to claim a connection that hasn’t been verified. What can be said honestly is this: Merle Haggard was, by multiple independent accounts, still actively sending Sturgill Simpson unfinished material in his final years — meaning whatever happened on that tour bus wasn’t an isolated moment. It was part of an ongoing, real creative relationship between two songwriters who genuinely respected each other’s work, right up until Haggard’s death. Simpson’s own career, in the years since, has only made Haggard’s early faith in him look better with time — proof, if any was still needed, that the ranch conversation had been two equals talking, not a legend indulging a fan.

---

Also on Classic Country TV: Haggard’s ranch conversation wasn’t the first time outlaw country’s older generation formally passed something to the next — see how that tradition played out with four of the genre’s biggest names. Read the story of The Highwaymen

---

Why This Conversation Still Matters

It would be easy to file “The Legend and the Renegade” away as just another celebrity-magazine profile — two well-known musicians, a nice photo spread, a handful of quotable lines. That undersells what actually happened on that ranch. This was one of country music’s defining outlaws, weeks from the end of his life though nobody sitting on that sofa knew it, taking a full day off from the touring schedule his own family was begging him to abandon, specifically to sit with the one younger artist he considered a genuine peer. He wasn’t handing Simpson a torch in any formal sense — Haggard wasn’t the type for ceremony. But he was doing something that mattered just as much: telling the truth, on the record, about what it actually costs to live a life built entirely around songs — the family strain, the physical toll, the songs that get away because there was no time to catch them.

That’s the story Classic Country TV exists to preserve — not just the hits and the highlight reels, but the unglamorous, honest conversations between the people who actually lived this music, before they’re gone and the only version left is whatever gets repeated at an awards show.

There’s a version of this story that gets told as pure sentiment — an aging legend blessing his successor before he goes. That version isn’t wrong, exactly, but it’s smaller than what actually happened. Haggard didn’t need Simpson’s career to validate his own; his place in country music was already permanent, already secure, whether or not anyone under 40 ever discovered him. What he seemed to want, instead, was simply to spend a rare free afternoon with someone who understood the specific, unglamorous math of the life he’d chosen — the bus, the family left waiting, the songs that either got caught or got lost. That’s not a torch-passing ceremony. It’s closer to two men comparing notes at the end of a long shift, grateful to find someone else who’d worked the same job.

Merle Haggard and Sturgill Simpson sat on a sofa together for one afternoon in the spring of 2016 and talked like two working men comparing notes on a job that had cost them both plenty and given them both everything. That’s worth remembering exactly as it happened.

Recommended Gear

Guitar & Instruments

Fender CD-60S Dreadnought Acoustic Guitar (Natural)
Every songwriter’s story in this piece starts with a guitar within reach — this is the kind of solid, honest workhorse dreadnought that earns its keep on a porch or a tour bus alike.
https://www.amazon.com/dp/B07FYBLG93/?tag=classiccoun08-20

Hohner Blues Harp Harmonica, Key of C
A pocket-sized companion for anyone chasing the kind of raw, unpolished sound Haggard spent his life defending against a slicker version of country music.
https://www.amazon.com/dp/B07G4HGYYR/?tag=classiccoun08-20

Leather Goods & Accessories

Vintage Leather Journal Notebook (6×8″, Handmade)
Haggard said the good songs feel handed to you — and the only trick is being ready to write them down. This is exactly the kind of notebook built for that job.
https://www.amazon.com/dp/B08MCBQY54/?tag=classiccoun08-20

DANIEL’S ARTPLANET Western Full-Grain Leather Belt, 1.5″
Handmade, one-piece full-grain leather with real Western tooling — the kind of built-to-last piece that fits the working-man ethos both artists in this story wrote about for decades.
https://www.amazon.com/dp/B0D9R9Y4B5/?tag=classiccoun08-20

Camping & Travel Gear

YETI Rambler 20 oz Tumbler, Stainless Steel (Black)
Every mile on a tour bus runs on coffee that stays hot and water that stays cold — this is the one that survives the whole trip.
https://www.amazon.com/dp/B073WJMKHN/?tag=classiccoun08-20

Amazon Basics Portable Folding Camping Chair with 4-Can Cooler
The kind of simple, sturdy chair that belongs parked beside a tour bus or a ranch pond on a rare day off — no frills, just somewhere to sit and talk.
https://www.amazon.com/dp/B0CZNY3LR8/?tag=classiccoun08-20

From the Classic Country TV Shop

Classic Country. No Apologies. — Statement Tee
A straightforward line for a straightforward artist who never much cared what Nashville thought of him.
https://classiccountrytv.com/products/classic-country-no-apologies-statement-tee-drop-001

Cracked Star Hat — Drop 001
An outlaw symbol for an outlaw story.
https://classiccountrytv.com/products/cracked-star-hat-classic-country-tv-drop-001

As an Amazon Associate, Classic Country TV earns from qualifying purchases.
Disclosure: Some links on this page are affiliate links. If you purchase through these links, Classic Country TV may earn a small commission at no additional cost to you.

Sources & Further Reading

Garden & Gun — “The Legend and the Renegade”
The primary source for this article: Matt Hendrickson’s 2016 conversation between Merle Haggard and Sturgill Simpson, photographed by David McClister, published in the April/May 2016 issue.
https://gardenandgun.com/the-legend-and-the-renegade

Taste of Country — “Merle Haggard Calls Contemporary Country Music ‘a Bunch of Crap'”
Corroborating coverage from spring 2016 confirming Haggard’s praise for Simpson and the Bluestem Center for the Arts show invitation.
https://www.foxnews.com/entertainment/merle-haggard-calls-contemporary-country-music-a-bunch-of-crap.print

Rolling Stone — “Sturgill Simpson: I Will Be ‘Blackballed From the Industry'”
Coverage of Simpson’s response to the ACM’s Merle Haggard Spirit Award, including his criticism of Garden & Gun’s cover decision, August 2016.
https://www.rollingstone.com/music/music-country/sturgill-simpson-i-will-be-blackballed-from-the-industry-251686

Nashville Scene — “How Sturgill Simpson Conquered Country Without Music Row”
Fall 2016 profile in which Simpson reflects on the ACM controversy and his decision to stay in Nashville.
https://www.nashvillescene.com/music/coverstory/how-sturgill-simpson-conquered-country-without-music-row/article_ef4eb531-b0bd-56de-a757-85eb7a1c2500.html

NPR — “Hear Sturgill Simpson’s ‘Cuttin’ Grass, Vol. 2: The Cowboy Arms Sessions’ Now”
Background on “Hobo Cartoon,” Simpson’s posthumous co-write with Merle Haggard, released December 2020.
https://www.npr.org/2020/12/11/945088769/hear-sturgill-simpsons-cuttin-grass-vol-2-the-cowboy-arms-sessions-now

Wikipedia — Merle Haggard
Biographical and career reference details, including birth, death, and career dates.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Merle_Haggard

Frequently Asked Questions